Editorial Standards & Legal Notice
These standards and notices apply to GIB’s reporting, investigations, commentary, graphics, downloads and archives.
Editorial freedom and public accountability
GIB publishes independent reporting, investigations, commentary and satire on matters of public concern. GIB asserts its rights to investigate, criticize, draw conclusions from disclosed facts, and exercise editorial judgment over what it publishes. It reserves all applicable constitutional, statutory and common-law defenses, including truth and substantial truth, protected opinion, fair reporting privileges, applicable fault standards and limitations on damages. Political disagreement, offense or an adverse account of a person’s public conduct does not by itself establish defamation.
Those rights are substantial, not unlimited. This notice does not exempt unlawful conduct, convert a false factual assertion into protected opinion, or establish that every item on this site qualifies for a particular legal defense.
Defense of protected reporting
GIB reserves the right to oppose claims targeting protected speech or petitioning through applicable anti-SLAPP procedures, including California Code of Civil Procedure section 425.16 where available. It may seek dismissal or an order striking covered claims, recoverable attorney fees and costs, and other relief authorized by law. Eligibility, exceptions, deadlines and the court in which a case is filed govern the remedies available; sanctions require their own legal basis.
GIB invokes California Civil Code section 47(d) and other applicable fair-report protections. California’s fair-and-true-report privilege is absolute against defamation within its qualifying scope; GIB must establish that the particular report meets its requirements. Reports should identify the official proceeding and preserve its substance and context. Repeating an outside accusation alone does not establish the privilege. Judicial Council guidance, CACI 1724
GIB reserves truth and substantial truth as defenses to defamation claims. Its factual reporting should be supported by preserved records sufficient to establish the substance of the challenged assertion. A source’s credibility, an allegation’s repetition or a political conclusion does not substitute for proof of the underlying facts. Judicial Council guidance, CACI 1720
For defamation claims concerning public officials’ official conduct, GIB invokes the constitutional requirement that the claimant prove actual malice by clear and convincing evidence: knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard of truth. Political hostility alone does not establish that standard. Other claimants and circumstances may be governed by different rules. New York Times v. Sullivan
Facts allegations and interpretation
Readers should distinguish documented events from allegations, disputed accounts, analysis, predictions and opinion. An accusation, investigation, lawsuit, impeachment proposal or indictment is not itself a finding of wrongdoing. The procedural status and supporting evidence identified in the relevant article matter.
Political criticism and conclusions drawn from disclosed facts express editorial judgment. A label such as “opinion,” “analysis,” “satire” or “alleged” does not settle whether a particular statement is legally actionable. Headlines, illustrations, captions and social previews must be read in context with the material they present, but context cannot cure every misleading implication.
Sources quotations and external material
Links, quotations and references identify material relevant to an article. Their inclusion is not a blanket endorsement of every assertion made by a source. External publishers control their own material, which may change or become unavailable.
Attribution identifies who made a statement; it does not automatically establish the statement’s truth or eliminate the legal consequences of republishing it. Reports of official proceedings should accurately identify the proceeding, the allegation and its current disposition. Applicable privileges depend on the jurisdiction and the actual report.
Corrections and responses
A person requesting a correction should identify the article URL and publication date, quote each challenged statement, explain the asserted factual error, provide supporting records, and identify the requester and a means of reply. Requests concerning headlines, photographs, graphics, social previews or downloadable copies should identify those items separately. These details facilitate review; they do not add conditions to legally sufficient statutory notice or extend any deadline.
GIB retains editorial control over responses, corrections, clarifications and updates, subject to applicable law. Reviewing a complaint, corresponding with a claimant or changing material does not by itself constitute GIB’s concession of liability or waiver of a defense. GIB reserves available defenses while addressing substantiated factual errors. Nothing in this notice restricts statutory rights, replaces legally required service or notice, or extends a legal deadline.
GIB reserves any applicable limitations on recoverable damages under California Civil Code section 48a. That section includes electronic news publications publishing at least weekly, but eligibility and compliance must be established from the actual publication and the circumstances of a claim. Any reliance on its correction provisions requires timely handling of demands and a correction satisfying the statute’s requirements. Enacted text, SB 1171 section 17
Corrections and editorial contact: Pkirbyr@gmail.com. Please include the article URL and identify the statement or material concerned.
Copyright and permitted use
Copyright in protectable original material belongs to its respective rights holder. GIB does not claim ownership of third-party works, public-domain material, facts or ideas. Any copyright claim in AI-assisted material extends only to protectable human authorship recognized by applicable law.
Readers may link to GIB pages. Reproduction beyond applicable legal exceptions requires permission from the relevant rights holder. Credit alone does not substitute for permission. Nothing in this notice restricts lawful fair use or other statutory rights.
Uses of third-party material must be supported by permission, a license, public-domain status or a defensible legal exception. Fair use is assessed case by case; neither an educational purpose nor a general fair-use notice guarantees that an entire article, video, transcript or image may be reproduced.
Copyright complaints
A copyright complaint should identify the protected work, the challenged material and its exact location, the claimant’s contact information and authority to act, and the factual basis for the complaint. Formal DMCA notices must satisfy applicable statutory requirements and be directed to the appropriate designated agent where one has been established.
This notice does not represent that GIB has registered a DMCA agent or qualifies for a statutory safe harbor. Those protections require actual eligibility and compliance, not merely publication of a disclaimer.
Commentary imagery and professional advice
Editorial illustrations, composites and satire should not be mistaken for documentary evidence. Their presentation should make that distinction clear where confusion is reasonably foreseeable. A satirical treatment does not license a false factual allegation about an identifiable person.
Site content is general information and commentary, not individualized legal, financial, medical or other professional advice. Reading or communicating with the site does not create an attorney-client relationship. Decisions requiring professional advice should be taken to an appropriately qualified professional.
Dates archives and limits
Publication and revision dates identify the relevant edition. An archived article reflects its historical context and should not be treated as a continuously updated account. Later developments may alter an earlier analysis.
No disclaimer guarantees accuracy, prevents a lawsuit or supplies absolute legal protection. Nothing here excludes a responsibility or remedy that applicable law does not permit to be excluded.