On crossing the Rubicon Original post: https://x.com/DataRepublican/status/2119600781896847702 User-supplied machine transcript. Time ranges are seconds in the edited compilation. Speakers and source dates follow the compilation; original audio and displayed documents have not all been independently authenticated. Transcription errors may remain. 0.29-2.33 What happens if officials refuse to certify an 2.33-2.65 election? 3.35-5.31 Refusing to certify would be treated as crossing 5.31-8.27 the Rubicon, a line that once crossed can't 8.27-9.13 be uncrossed. 9.33-10.75 Before we can talk about what that would 10.75-12.63 mean, we have to be honest about three 12.63-13.09 things. 13.57-15.35 What actually happened on November 3rd? 15.69-18.21 What the most popular fraud claims say, and 18.21-20.05 why even the real problems in our election 20.05-21.71 system can't win in court. 22.17-23.51 First, what happened? 23.91-26.15 Democrats won a national wave, and it was 26.15-27.97 close to the same size almost everywhere. 27.97-31.79 About 123.5 million ballots were cast. 32.11-34.01 That's the most ever cast in a midterm. 34.59-36.53 In the House, the national vote went from 36.53-39.89 Republicans plus 2.6 in 2024 to Democrats 39.89-42.75 plus 12.9. That's bigger than the 2018 42.75-45.79 blue wave, which was Democrats plus 8.6. 46.25-48.99 In the Senate, 29 of 30 races moved 48.99-52.03 toward Democrats from the 2024 presidential vote by 52.03-53.83 16.5 points on average. 53.83-56.41 The states kept almost exactly the same order. 56.89-57.99 They all moved together. 58.51-60.29 Early voting shows who drove it. 60.67-63.01 In North Carolina, early ballots from registered Democrats 63.01-65.17 were up 31 percent over 2022. 65.83-68.23 Unaffiliated voters up 51 percent. 68.65-70.41 Republicans up just nine. 70.87-72.61 Nevada and Florida moved the same way. 73.07-74.85 Pennsylvania's mail vote was the one exception. 75.57-76.65 Some voters did switch. 77.09-79.63 In the NBC News exit poll, 7 percent 79.63-82.43 of 2024 Trump voters voted Democratic this time. 82.43-84.63 2 percent of Harris voters went Republican. 85.17-87.21 But the bigger story is who showed up. 87.59-88.85 Democratic turnout surged. 89.29-90.95 Republican turnout barely moved. 91.47-92.41 Now, the theories. 92.93-94.53 Here are five of the most shared this 94.53-96.47 week, some of them reposted by the president 96.47-96.97 himself. 97.47-99.55 Each one tested on its own terms. 100.05-102.17 One, Republican votes stayed the same. 102.59-104.93 Democrats materialized 20 million new votes. 105.39-107.39 That post has been seen about 5 million 107.39-107.91 times. 108.41-109.61 The numbers are about right. 110.01-111.79 The question is whether a jump that size 111.79-112.23 is new. 112.43-113.25 It isn't. 113.61-116.99 From 2014 to 2018, House Democrats gained almost 116.99-118.33 25 million votes. 118.77-120.59 That's more than this year's 19 million. 121.19-123.57 Two, the 85-15 algorithm. 124.07-125.63 This chart has been everywhere. 126.15-128.29 The claim, for every 1,000 Trump votes 128.29-131.91 in 2024, only about 850 stayed Republican. 132.39-133.27 In every state. 133.63-134.47 That's not a swing. 134.89-135.71 That's an algorithm. 136.21-138.31 We ran their formula, and it checks out, 138.59-141.75 .85. Then, we ran the same formula on 141.75-143.03 earlier wave midterms. 143.43-151.37 2006, .86. 2010, .88. 2018, .89. If it's 151.37-153.79 an algorithm, it ran against Obama in 2010, 153.99-154.21 too. 154.67-156.59 A president's party shrinking by about the same 156.59-158.95 fraction everywhere is what a midterm wave looks 158.95-159.25 like. 159.63-160.87 Three, the counties. 161.39-165.37 2,848 counties moved toward Democrats out of 165.37-166.97 3,109. 166.97-170.19 As it spread, move toward became flipped. 170.67-171.95 Those aren't the same thing. 172.41-175.25 In Texas in 2018, a smaller wave, about 175.25-178.21 71% of counties moved toward Democrats, and 178.21-179.09 only 6 flipped. 179.47-181.99 In a wave, almost every county moves in 181.99-182.81 the same direction. 183.17-184.39 Four, Texas. 184.75-187.33 The claim is that James Tallarico got 500 187.33-189.49 ,000 more votes than Kamala Harris did in 189.49-192.15 the presidential election, and that this is impossible. 192.49-194.37 The first part is true. 194.37-197.31 Tallarico has about 5.4 million votes. 197.77-200.05 Harris got about 4.8 million, but it 200.05-201.07 has happened before. 201.55-204.43 In 2018, Beto O'Rourke got 4.05 204.43-207.15 million votes in Texas, more than Hillary Clinton's 207.15-209.23 3.88 million two years earlier. 209.79-212.65 A second version, that Texas turnout beat 2024, 213.43-214.07 is false. 214.49-217.53 About 9.8 million ballots against 11.4 217.53-217.89 million. 218.39-221.61 Five, Lancaster, Pennsylvania officials have busted a large 221.61-223.53 -scale fraudulent voter registration scheme. 223.53-225.49 It went around this week as news. 225.97-227.25 It's from October 2024. 227.95-229.77 About 2,500 applications. 230.43-232.61 According to VoteBeat, none of the ones identified 232.61-234.85 as fraudulent were processed, added a voter to 234.85-236.69 the rolls, or led to a ballot. 237.07-238.01 The county caught it. 238.33-239.13 Two years ago. 239.65-240.35 Five theories. 240.93-241.55 Five checks. 242.03-243.43 None of them shows what it claims. 243.95-245.37 Now, I want to say this as strongly 245.37-246.07 as I can. 246.57-248.31 None of this is proof that fraud doesn't 248.31-248.69 exist. 249.19-251.19 A meme failing tells you nothing about whether 251.19-252.17 the system is sound. 252.17-254.33 These checks can't see a small number of 254.33-256.17 illegal ballots spread across many places. 256.67-258.57 And the records that could see them mostly 258.57-259.25 aren't public. 259.77-261.55 Bad arguments also do real damage. 262.09-264.05 Every theory that falls apart makes the next 264.05-265.55 real problem harder to raise. 265.99-267.31 So let's talk about real ones. 267.85-268.61 Start with Alaska. 269.13-271.53 The Senate ballot had two Dan Sullivans, the 271.53-274.23 Republican senator and a retired teacher who registered 274.23-276.19 as a Republican two days before he filed 276.19-276.63 to run. 276.63-279.33 On October 28th, the New York Times reported 279.33-281.67 on what it called a ballot composition project 281.67-284.23 tied to Mary Peltola's campaign and the Democratic 284.23-287.03 Senatorial Campaign Committee to find as many people 287.03-289.07 named Dan Sullivan in Alaska as possible. 289.49-291.41 The Times reports a federal grand jury is 291.41-291.95 investigating. 292.47-294.75 What happened in Alaska was blatant, and it 294.75-296.85 should be litigated fully in court. 297.33-298.89 Then there's the machinery itself. 299.33-301.87 These are real, documented transparency problems. 302.21-304.31 The code that counts our votes is proprietary. 304.88-307.01 Three vendors hold about 85 percent of the 307.01-307.27 market. 307.75-309.45 And I couldn't find a single public records 309.45-311.61 ruling that opened a major vendor's source code. 312.13-314.47 About 43 states don't require a risk-limiting 314.47-315.23 audit by law. 315.69-318.03 And Louisiana still votes on paperless machines. 318.45-320.41 So there's no voter-verified paper to audit 320.41-320.89 at all. 321.41-322.97 And audits don't touch eligibility. 323.49-324.31 Who's on the rolls? 324.61-325.57 Whose signature matches? 326.03-326.75 Who's a citizen? 327.21-329.57 From the outside, those checks are mostly invisible. 330.09-331.79 So take these real problems to court. 332.15-333.93 Here's why they almost never win. 333.93-335.37 Start with the evidence. 335.83-336.67 Much of it is sealed. 337.13-337.79 Trade secrets. 338.11-338.77 Protective orders. 339.17-339.85 The secret ballot. 340.27-341.95 And a court wants evidence before it will 341.95-343.31 order access to the evidence. 343.83-344.53 Then standing. 345.01-347.59 If a problem affects everyone, no single voter 347.59-348.13 can sue. 348.61-350.91 A federal appeals court called vote dilution a 350.91-352.77 paradigmatic generalized grievance. 353.11-355.31 The bigger the problem, the weaker any one 355.31-355.95 voter's case. 356.35-357.33 Then timing. 357.81-360.83 Before an election, your harm is speculative, or 360.83-362.01 it's too close to the vote. 362.01-364.51 After the election, you waited too long. 365.05-366.83 Even if you get in, you have to 366.83-368.05 prove the outcome changed. 368.49-371.01 In Arizona, a court rejected the argument that 371.01-373.73 some unquantifiable uncertainty suffices. 374.21-375.87 Get it wrong, and you pay. 376.39-379.09 Sanctions for lawyers and defamation verdicts as high 379.09-380.67 as $148 million. 381.47-383.63 Try to gather the evidence yourself, and it's 383.63-384.05 a crime. 384.49-386.79 In Mesa County, Colorado, and Coffey County, Georgia, 387.21-389.69 people copied election software without authorization. 390.25-391.69 Both led to criminal charges. 392.01-395.33 Look at curling versus Raffensperger filed in 2017. 396.09-397.93 After years of litigation and a full trial, 398.29-400.43 the judge wrote in March 2025 that the 400.43-403.81 plaintiffs presented substantial evidence supporting their deeply held 403.81-404.39 concerns. 404.89-407.27 Then she dismissed the case anyway, for lack 407.27-407.77 of standing. 408.01-410.51 The cases that did win look nothing like 410.51-410.83 that. 411.19-413.13 North Carolina's ninth district in 2018. 413.69-415.33 Patterson, New Jersey in 2020. 415.73-417.29 Bridgeport, Connecticut in 2023. 417.93-419.37 All small and local. 419.37-423.39 All about physical ballots proven with investigators, insiders, 423.53-423.93 or video. 424.45-426.23 And each time, the remedy was a new 426.23-428.21 election, not a reversed result. 428.79-431.17 A systemic or software theory can't fit that 431.17-431.49 shape. 431.89-432.83 The evidence is digital. 433.33-434.31 The scale is large. 434.67-436.75 The insiders are vendors, and no one can 436.75-438.01 isolate the affected ballots. 438.45-440.75 You can't get the evidence without proof, and 440.75-442.69 you can't get proof without the evidence. 446.10-448.04 So the courts won't hear a mass fraud 448.04-448.40 case. 448.72-450.84 And refusing to certify has been tried. 450.84-452.32 Wayne County, Michigan. 452.82-454.16 Otero County, New Mexico. 454.76-455.94 Cochise County, Arizona. 456.50-458.70 Every one ended in certification within days. 459.18-461.62 In Cochise County, two supervisors were indicted. 462.14-464.36 This year, the Justice Department asked a court 464.36-466.12 to hold up Alaska's Senate certification. 466.68-468.90 On November 1st, the judge threw it out. 469.32-471.38 That leaves two moves people are talking about. 471.80-475.18 Refusing to seat the winners and emergency powers. 475.64-477.60 Refusing to seat a whole new majority has 477.60-478.40 never been done. 478.40-482.48 In 1865 and 1985, the House did refuse 482.48-483.14 to seat members. 483.66-485.50 Both times, it was the new majority doing 485.50-485.76 it. 486.18-488.58 And no president has ever used emergency powers 488.58-490.62 or the Insurrection Act to decide an election. 491.22-492.58 Either one would be unprecedented. 493.10-494.92 And the other side has already decided what 494.92-495.32 it means. 495.76-497.10 They don't treat it as a legal fight. 497.48-499.10 They treat it as crossing the Rubicon. 499.56-501.34 And they've planned for it, in writing. 501.68-504.46 In 2020, a group called the Transition Integrity 504.46-507.12 Project war-gamed a disputed election with 67 507.12-509.72 players, including career federal employees. 510.14-511.70 Judicial Watch published the report. 512.14-514.34 Its conclusion, this may well be a street 514.34-515.54 fight, not a legal battle. 516.02-518.80 In one game, the Biden team encouraged California, 519.12-521.18 Oregon, and Washington to secede from the union 521.18-523.56 unless Republicans agreed to structural reforms. 524.04-526.10 This year, the planning came back, with a 526.10-526.34 date. 526.74-529.14 The seating of the 120th Congress on January 529.14-530.50 3rd, 2027. 531.10-532.18 Indivisible's Toolkit. 532.18-534.46 If Trump and his allies try refusing to 534.46-536.42 seat the election winners, they will be ready 536.42-538.44 to mobilize for large-scale protests. 538.62-541.16 If Trump tries to deny the results of 541.16-543.36 the election, if they're trying to seize ballots 543.36-546.00 or refuse to seat the winners, it's on 546.00-548.06 us to make sure that society has to 548.06-550.06 stop and pay attention to that, right? 550.08-551.20 That they don't just move on. 551.36-554.84 That the cloud and confusion that Trump and 554.84-557.02 Stephen Miller want doesn't let them just sneak 557.02-557.44 this by. 557.44-560.94 And this thing that we've all built together 560.94-563.34 is the ability to get millions of our 563.34-565.28 friends together to demand hell no. 565.60-566.92 And we're going to count every vote. 567.32-569.88 On a national call in October, Indivisible's Leah 569.88-571.10 Greenberg gave the clock. 571.44-573.14 But the important thing to stress is that 573.14-575.66 once there's that call for rapid response, we're 575.66-576.30 going to move fast. 576.38-578.78 We're talking people out on the streets within 578.78-580.12 24 to 48 hours. 580.12-581.24 We're not going to wait for a weekend. 581.58-583.38 We have to be prepared to respond to 583.38-584.98 threats with ongoing mobilization. 584.98-587.32 We're talking about an action that carries a 587.32-589.78 clear demand and that continues until that demand 589.78-590.32 is met. 590.50-593.00 Organizing documents from April have a section titled, 593.18-595.64 in their words, when the Rubicon is crossed. 595.98-596.54 The triggers. 597.10-598.82 If duly elected leaders are not seated. 599.12-601.32 If certification is suspended through delay. 601.80-602.38 The response. 602.90-604.08 Occupations of capitals. 604.62-605.30 General strikes. 605.82-607.36 The daily order of things suspended. 607.98-610.38 Permits for January 3rd and 4th in D 610.38-613.04 .C. Governors and mayors who have already decided 613.04-613.78 what they will do. 613.78-616.24 A strategy that has to run through February 616.24-617.70 and March of 2027. 618.36-620.78 Another plan reaches out to senior military, intelligence 620.78-623.02 and law enforcement officials so they know in 623.02-625.54 advance how they will uphold their oath if 625.54-627.30 the president invokes the Insurrection Act. 627.76-630.18 On one network call, an organizer said a 630.18-633.18 coalition had identified four red lines and was 633.18-634.74 building a situation room. 635.95-640.08 They have identified four red lines for mobilization 640.08-643.98 and they're developing a situation room and indicators 643.98-648.46 and a very sophisticated, like, peace room, I 648.46-651.32 call it, to track what's going to be 651.32-653.60 unfolding this fall and then to respond. 653.86-655.60 And don't count on Senate Republicans to hold 655.60-656.38 the line for him. 656.82-659.38 Mitch McConnell, January 6th, 2021. 659.96-662.28 If this election were overturned by mere allegations 662.28-664.76 from the losing side, our democracy would enter 664.76-665.58 a death spiral. 665.58-670.46 This election were overturned by mere allegations from 670.46-671.46 the losing side. 671.86-673.78 Our democracy would enter a death spiral. 674.16-677.80 We'd never see the whole nation accept an 677.80-678.60 election again. 678.80-680.68 Every four years would be a scramble for 680.68-682.24 power at any cost. 682.42-683.06 Mike Pence. 683.54-685.28 I had no right to overturn the election. 685.66-688.54 And I heard this week that President Trump 688.54-691.10 said I had the right to overturn the 691.10-691.48 election. 691.94-693.14 But President Trump is wrong. 693.88-696.64 I had no right to overturn the election. 696.88-700.20 The presidency belongs to the American people and 700.20-701.60 the American people alone. 701.92-705.00 Over January 6th, seven Republican senators voted to 705.00-705.52 convict him. 706.02-707.84 That was over a speech and a riot. 708.32-710.32 Refusing to see to Congress is far bigger. 710.82-712.60 This time it would take about a dozen 712.60-714.78 and removal is already on the table. 714.78-717.38 Bill Kristol, a player in that 2020 war 717.38-720.38 game, wrote in April that early in 2027, 720.86-723.24 Congress should take responsibility and remove him from 723.24-723.58 office. 724.02-726.38 In 2020, Joe Biden said that if Trump 726.38-730.08 refused to leave, he was absolutely convinced the 730.08-732.12 military would escort him from the White House. 732.46-733.46 Let me let me ask you this, and 733.46-734.76 I know this is a strange question to 734.76-737.08 ask an American politician, maybe easier around the 737.08-737.24 world. 737.32-739.44 But have you ever considered what would happen 739.44-742.14 if the election results came out as you 742.14-743.84 being the winner and Trump refused to leave? 744.78-745.68 Yes, I have. 745.78-746.92 And I was so damn proud. 747.06-749.92 You have four chiefs of staff coming out 749.92-751.94 and ripping the skin off of Trump. 752.76-756.14 And you have so many rank and file 756.14-759.50 military personnel saying, whoa, we're not a military 759.50-759.98 state. 760.06-761.12 This is not who we are. 761.40-763.90 I promise you, I'm absolutely convinced they will 763.90-766.58 escort him from the White House with great 766.58-767.08 dispatch. 767.34-768.54 So here is the other side of that 768.54-770.34 line in their own plans. 770.34-774.22 Within hours, lawyers, within 24 to 48 hours, 774.64-778.04 people in the streets, occupations of capitals, general 778.04-781.00 strikes, governors acting on decisions they've already made, 781.50-784.36 officers reminded of their oath, an impeachment and 784.36-786.08 Republican senators ready to convict. 786.46-788.60 It ends with the president removed from office 788.60-790.80 and everything that comes the day after. 791.48-794.08 That is the Rubicon, not a line Trump 794.08-796.18 has crossed, a line they are waiting for 796.18-796.80 him to cross. 797.12-799.74 And once it's crossed, our republic doesn't come 799.74-800.08 back.